Community-Shirley Insurance, LLC. was established in 2009, as the result of a merger between Community Insurance (founded in 1992, by Robin Stamps) and Shirley Insurance (founded in 1981, by Tom Shirley Sr).  We are a full service Insurance Agency offering Auto, Home, Life, Commercial, and many other Insurance Products to fit your needs.

We take great pride in the fact that our agency continues to grow each year, largely due to our clients.  Referrals comprise about 90% of our new business each year.  We attribute this to the fact that we are laser-focused on service above all else.  We have eight full time agents available from 9-5 Monday-Friday to provide quotes, endorse policies, process claims, and answer questions, quickly and professionally. We are also available after-hours by appointment.

Since we are an Independent Agency, we offer policies and products from a variety of companies, chosen specifically by our Agents to provide you with the absolute best coverage for your dollar. We believe this gives us a product and service advantage over other agencies that may represent only one or a few companies.

Give us a call today and see what we can do for you!

If you need to file a claim and it is during business hours please call us at 937-898-9010

When the accident occurred you must call the police no matter how minor it may seem. Take notes, make sure you know what date, time, where the accident occurred (be as specific as possible) and  how the accident happened.

Take pictures of the vehicles that were involved and a description of each vehicle's damage.

Get the names and contact information of those involved in the accident and the names and contact information of anyone who may have witnessed the accident.

If it is after hours please contact your insurance company directly.

​Erie 1-800-367-3743http://www.erieinsurance.comOhio Mutual 1-888-895-7725http://omig.comPekin 1-888-735-4611http://www.pekininsurance.com Grange 1-800-445-3030www.grangeinsurance.comEncompass 1-800-588-7400www.encompassinsurance.comTravelers 1-800-252-4633https://www.travelers.comAmerican Commerce  1-800-222-2114Alfa Vision 1-877-584-7466www.alfavision.comProgressive 1-800-274-4499http://www.progressive.comVictoria/Titan 1-800-888-8424https://www.titan.comThe General 1-800-280-1466http://www.thegeneral.com

Community - Shirley

7801 North Dixie Dive

Dayton, OH 45414

​